When choosing wood for your privacy fence, cedar and redwood often come to mind. Both of these woods have unique qualities that make them attractive choices for fencing, but deciding between them can be tough. This article takes a closer look at cedar and redwood and what makes them the best wood for privacy fence. It also compares their characteristics, durability, maintenance requirements, and environmental considerations to help you make an informed choice for your privacy fencing needs.
Cedar vs. Redwood: A Closer Look
Wood Characteristics
Cedar
Cedar is famous for its natural beauty and aroma. It has a reddish-brown color with distinct grain patterns. Cedar’s appearance can vary slightly depending on the type of cedar used, with Western Red Cedar and Eastern Red Cedar being two common options.
Redwood
Redwood, as the name suggests, boasts a rich reddish hue. It is another softwood that is naturally rot-resistant and highly durable. Redwood’s color and grain patterns make it a visually appealing choice for any outdoor structure.
Durability
Cedar
Cedar is naturally resistant to decay, insect infestations, and rot. However, it is less durable than redwood, which means it may require more maintenance over time. Cedar can last 15 to 30 years, depending on climate conditions and maintenance efforts.
Redwood
Redwood is renowned for its exceptional durability. It contains natural oils and tannins that make it resistant to decay and insects. With proper care, redwood fences can last several decades, often exceeding 30 years or more. This longevity is one of the main reasons why redwood is a preferred choice for privacy fencing.
Maintenance Requirements
Cedar
Cedar fences require more maintenance compared to redwood. They need regular staining or sealing to maintain their appearance and extend their lifespan. Without proper maintenance, cedar can deteriorate more quickly, losing its color and structural integrity.
Redwood
Redwood, on the other hand, requires minimal maintenance. Its natural resistance to decay and insects means you don’t need to invest as much time and effort in preserving its quality. While some homeowners choose to seal or stain their redwood fences for aesthetic reasons, it’s not a necessity for the wood’s longevity.
Environmental Considerations
Cedar
Cedar is considered an environmentally friendly choice for fencing because it is a renewable resource. Cedar trees are often harvested sustainably, and their fast growth rate makes them a practical choice for minimizing environmental impact.
Redwood
Redwood also ranks high in terms of environmental sustainability. Most redwood used for fencing is sourced from second-growth or third-growth trees, ensuring the conservation of old-growth redwood forests. The long lifespan of redwood fencing further contributes to its eco-friendliness by reducing the need for frequent replacement.
Cost Comparison
Cedar
Cedar is generally more affordable than redwood, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. While it may require more maintenance over time, the initial cost savings can be significant.
Redwood
Redwood is a premium wood option and tends to be more expensive than cedar. However, it has a long lifespan and requires minimal maintenance, both of which can offset the higher initial cost in the long run.
In conclusion, cedar and redwood are the best wood for privacy fence, each with its unique qualities. While cedar may be more budget-friendly, redwood shines in terms of durability and minimal maintenance. Consider your requirements when making your decision, and you’ll be well on your way to a beautiful and functional privacy fence that stands the test of time.